Saturday, September 20, 2014

Intel Z97 Motherboard Roundup: Asus, Asrock, EVGA, MSI & Gigabyte

When Haswell replaced Ivy Bridge last year it came accompanied by Intel's 8-series chipset. Codenamed 'Lynx Point', the Z87 flagshipoffered broader SATA 6Gb/s support, more USB 3.0 ports, and did so while consuming almost 40% less power.

It had been expected that the Z87 chipset would see the Haswell range out, but this June delivered a Haswell refresh and along with some rebadged CPUs we got the new 9-series chipset and a successor to the Z87. Codenamed 'Wildcat Point', the new Z97 was virtually identical to its predecessor with a few exceptions.

The most noteworthy change was support for future Broadwell CPUs, which should arrive during the coming holiday shopping period. In addition to compatibility with future processors, the Z97 brought SATA Express as well as the M.2 socket (briefly known as NGFF or the next generation form factor after mSATA).

M.2 is a specification for internally mounted storage and add-in cards. First designed for mobile devices, the M.2 interface has found its way into desktops and the new Z97 and H97 chipsets have played a big role in speeding up its adoption as a replacement for mSATA, which uses the PCI Express Mini Card physical layout.
Having a smaller and more flexible specification together with more advanced features, the M.2 is better suited for solid-state storage applications in general, especially when used in small devices like ultrabooks or tablets.

SATA Express is less promising in our opinion as it doesn't currently have supporting SSD devices. Whereas the M.2 socket is typically shared with one SATA 6Gb/s port, the SATA Express interface takes two SATA 6Gb/s ports and requires a third smaller port which deals with PCI-Express based communications.

With over 90 motherboards available right now using the Z97 chipset, picking the right one can be a difficult decision. Hoping to narrow the search down, we have taken seven popular boards and compared them in just about every way possible.

We've included a total of seven boards from Asus, Asrock, EVGA Gigabyte and MSI in this roundup. Check out the comparisson table below for a quick glance at the features offered by each or skip to the respective page for a more detailed rundown.

Asus Z97-
Deluxe
MSI Z97
Mpower Max AC
Asrock Z97 Extreme9Asus Z97-Pro WiFi/ACGigabyte Z97X-UD5H-BKEVGA Z97
FTW
Asrock Z97 Extreme6
Price$275$250$240$210$200$170$165
Dual PCIe x16x8 / x8x8 / x8x16 / x16x8 / x8x16 / x8x8 / x8x8 / x8
Triple PCIe x16x16 / x8 / x4x8 / x4 / x4x8 / x8 / x16x16 / x8 / x4x16 / x8 / x4x8 / x4 / x4x8 / x8 / x2
Quad PCIe x16No SupportNo Supportx8 / x8 / x8 / x8No SupportNo Supportx8 / x4 / x4 / x1No Support
mini-PCI Express SlotNo SupportNo Supportx1No SupportNo SupportNo Supportx1
SATA 6Gb/sx6x8x10x6x8x8x10
SATA Expressx2No Supportx2x1x1No Supportx1
M.21 x M.2 (NGFF)1 x M.2 (NGFF)1 x M.2 (NGFF)
1 x Ultra M.2 Gen3 x4
1 x M.2 (NGFF)1 x M.2 (NGFF)No Support1 x M.2 (NGFF)
1 x Ultra M.2 Gen3 x4
M.2 Supported Length60 and 80mm42, 60 and 80mm30, 42, 60, 80 and 110 mm60 and 80mm42, 60 and 80mmNo Support30, 42, 60, 80 and 110 mm
eSATANo SupportNo Supportx1No SupportNo SupportNo Supportx1
Storage Interfaces9915810814
Maximum Usable781278812
AudioRealtek ALC1150Realtek ALC1150Realtek ALC1150Realtek ALC1150Realtek ALC1150Realtek ALC898Realtek ALC1150
NetworkDual Gigabit LAN
Intel I218V & Intel I211AT
Single Gigabit LAN
Intel I218V
Dual Gigabit LAN
Intel I218V & Intel I211AT
Single Gigabit LAN
Intel I218V
Dual Gigabit LAN
Intel I217V & Killer E2201
Single Gigabit LAN
Intel I217
Dual Gigabit LAN
Intel I218V & Realtek RTL8111GR
WiFiWi-Fi 802.11ac + Bluetooth 4.0Wi-Fi 802.11ac + Bluetooth 4.0No SupportWi-Fi 802.11ac + Bluetooth 4.0No SupportNo SupportNo Support
USB 3.0x10 (6 rear/4 onboard)x12 (8 rear/4 onboard)x8 (4 rear/4 onboard)x8 (4 rear/4 onboard)x8 (6 rear/2 onboard)x6 (4 rear/2 onboard)x10 (6 rear/4 onboard)
ThunderBoltNo SupportNo SupportNo SupportNo SupportNo SupportNo SupportNo Support
Display OutputsDisplayPort, Mini DisplayPort, HDMIHDMI, DisplayPortHDMI, DisplayPortHDMI, DisplayPort, VGA, HDMIHDMI, VGA, DVIHDMI, DisplayPortHDMI, DisplayPort, DVI
Form FactorATX 305 x 244mmATX 305 x 244mmATX 305 x 244mmATX 305 x 244mmATX 305 x 244mmATX 305 x 244mmATX 305 x 244mm

5 comments: